Janette Hartz-Karp, a professor at the Sustainability Policy Institute at Curtin University, has a sortition advocacy piece in The Conversation. It covers well known ground: history, diversity, deliberation, applications in Australia, etc.
The opening of the “What’s the obstacle to reform?” section is interesting:
So why isn’t deliberative democracy happening more often? Simple. Those in power are wary about sharing their power.
Unlike the Athenians, we don’t believe that every citizen is capable of participating in important decision-making. We assume most people are too self-interested to make decisions for the common good.
This seems to conflate two different ideas:
- Resistance by the elite,
- Anti-democratic sentiments in the population.
The first idea is clear and presents a general phenomenon. Power concedes nothing without a demand.
The second idea, however, is more intriguing. How resistant are the people themselves to democratic rule? If they are, why? An empirical study of this question could be useful.
The article also generated a lively conversation in the comments.